Re-engagement Sequence for Influencer Managers Email Guide
Why Re-engagement Sequence Emails Fail for Influencer Managers (And How to Fix Them)
An influencer you onboarded months ago just went silent. Your follow-up emails vanish into the void.
That's not just a lost connection, it's a missed opportunity for your clients and your agency. Many influencer managers find themselves with a growing list of contacts who once showed interest but have since gone quiet.
It's easy to let these relationships fade, especially when you're focused on active campaigns and new outreach. But these dormant connections represent significant untapped potential.
A strategic re-engagement sequence doesn't just revive old leads; it reminds past collaborators of your value, surfaces new needs, and reignites conversations that can lead to lucrative partnerships and expanded services for your clients. The templates below are designed to cut through the noise, showing genuine care while subtly reminding them of the results you can deliver.
The Complete 4-Email Re-engagement Sequence for Influencer Managers
As an influencer manager, your clients trust your recommendations. This 4-email sequence helps you introduce valuable tools without sounding like a salesperson.
The Miss You
Acknowledge the silence and show you care
Hi [First Name],
We haven't connected in a while, and I realized it's been too long since we last spoke about [SHARED TOPIC OR PAST INTERACTION]. I know how busy managing influencer relationships can be, with campaigns launching and new creators emerging constantly.
It's easy to lose touch. But I was thinking about [SPECIFIC VALUE YOU PROVIDE, e.g., securing high-ROI partnerships, simplifying onboarding, finding niche talent] and wondered if you've faced any new challenges in that area recently.
My door is always open if you're exploring new ways to enhance your client's brand presence or improve your influencer strategies. No pressure, just a friendly hello.
Best, [YOUR NAME]
This email uses the principle of reciprocity by offering value without asking for anything in return initially. It uses a soft, open-ended question to invite a low-commitment response, making it easy for the recipient to re-engage on their own terms.
The Value Reminder
Remind them why they subscribed
Hi [First Name],
When you first connected with us, it was likely because you were looking for solutions around [INITIAL PAIN POINT/GOAL, e.g., finding authentic creators, scaling outreach, improving campaign ROI]. Many influencer managers struggle with [COMMON CHALLENGE, e.g., vetting new talent efficiently, keeping up with platform changes, proving campaign effectiveness to clients].
These challenges can impact client satisfaction and campaign results. Our approach helps address these directly, ensuring your clients always connect with the right audience through effective campaigns.
We focus on delivering tangible results, not just engagements. If any of these challenges resonate with you right now, or if your needs have evolved, I'd be happy to share how we're helping others in your position.
Best, [YOUR NAME]
This email re-establishes relevance by reminding the recipient of the problem they initially sought to solve. It uses problem-agitation-solution (PAS) by highlighting a common pain point before subtly reintroducing your services as the answer, tapping into their original motivation.
The Survey
Ask what they actually want from you
Hi [First Name],
It's been a while, and I wanted to make sure I'm still sending you content that's actually useful for your work as an influencer manager. The of creator partnerships is always shifting.
What's the biggest challenge you're facing right now managing your clients' influencer campaigns or growing your talent roster? Are you more interested in strategies for [TOPIC 1, e.g., improving campaign budgets], insights into [TOPIC 2, e.g., new platform trends], or best practices for [TOPIC 3, e.g., long-term creator relationships]?
Just hit reply and let me know. Your feedback helps me tailor future communications to be genuinely helpful.
Best, [YOUR NAME]
This email employs the 'foot-in-the-door' technique by asking a small, easy-to-answer question. It makes the recipient feel valued and heard, increasing the likelihood of a reply. The multiple-choice format reduces friction, making it even easier to engage.
The Breakup
Give a final chance before removing them
Hi [First Name],
I've noticed we haven't heard from you in a while, and I understand that in the fast-paced world of influencer management, inboxes can get crowded. My goal is to provide valuable insights and solutions for improving client campaigns and talent relationships.
If that's no longer a priority for you, or if our content isn't hitting the mark, that's perfectly fine. I'll be removing inactive contacts from our list soon to ensure we're only reaching those who truly benefit from our updates.
If you still want to stay connected and receive our tips on [CORE VALUE PROPOSITION], simply click the link below to confirm your interest. Otherwise, this will be our last message.
No hard feelings either way! [CTA: Yes, I want to stay connected!]
Best, [YOUR NAME]
This email effectively uses loss aversion, a powerful psychological trigger. By stating the intent to remove them from the list, it creates a sense of potential loss, prompting them to take action if they value your content. It also maintains a positive, no-pressure tone.
4 Re-engagement Sequence Mistakes Influencer Managers Make
| Don't Do This | Do This Instead |
|---|---|
✕ Over-relying on a few top-tier creators for all campaigns, leading to burnout or limited audience reach. | Diversify your talent pool by actively scouting micro-influencers and niche creators who can offer specialized reach and authentic engagement for specific client campaigns. |
✕ Not tracking long-term ROI beyond initial campaign metrics, making it hard to prove sustained value to clients. | Implement CRM and analytics solutions to monitor brand lift, sentiment, and sales attribution over several months, demonstrating the enduring impact of influencer partnerships. |
✕ Manual outreach and follow-ups for talent acquisition and client prospecting, consuming valuable time. | Automate initial outreach using email marketing tools for talent discovery and client lead nurturing. Use scheduling software for efficient coordination of vetting calls and proposal presentations. |
✕ Underestimating the importance of clear, consistent communication with creators, leading to misaligned content or missed deadlines. | Develop comprehensive briefing templates and implement regular check-in protocols. Use shared documents or project management tools to ensure creators fully understand campaign objectives and deliverables. |
Re-engagement Sequence Timing Guide for Influencer Managers
When you send matters as much as what you send.
The Miss You
Acknowledge the silence and show you care
The Value Reminder
Remind them why they subscribed
The Survey
Ask what they actually want from you
The Breakup
Give a final chance before removing them
Use after 30-90 days of no opens or clicks.
Customize Re-engagement Sequence for Your Influencer Manager Specialty
Adapt these templates for your specific industry.
Talent Managers
- Implement a tiered communication strategy in your CRM for active, warm, and cold talent leads to ensure timely, personalized follow-ups.
- Use email marketing tools to send personalized updates to your roster about new brand opportunities, industry trends, or skill-building resources.
- Use scheduling software to manage multiple talent discovery calls, contract negotiations, and content review sessions efficiently.
Brand Partnership Managers
- Create automated sequences in your email marketing platform to nurture potential brand leads, sharing success stories and relevant case studies.
- Utilize your CRM to meticulously track brand preferences, past campaign performance, and long-term goals, informing highly tailored future partnership proposals.
- Schedule regular check-ins with existing brand clients using scheduling software to proactively identify new campaign needs and maintain strong relationships.
Campaign Managers
- Set up automated reminders within your CRM for key campaign milestones, ensuring all deliverables from influencers are met on time and within budget.
- Use email marketing tools to distribute comprehensive campaign briefs and critical updates to all participating influencers simultaneously, maintaining consistent communication.
- Integrate scheduling software for seamless coordination of content approvals, live event participation, and post-campaign debriefs with creators and clients.
Creator Economy Consultants
- Develop re-engagement email sequences specifically for past consulting clients, offering updated industry insights, new service packages, or exclusive workshop invitations.
- Track the specific challenges, goals, and growth trajectories of each creator client in your CRM to offer highly personalized advice and solutions as their careers evolve.
- Use scheduling software to manage a high volume of discovery calls, strategy sessions, and follow-up meetings with creators looking to grow their business and personal brand.
Ready to Save Hours?
You now have everything: 4 complete email templates, the psychology behind each one, when to send them, common mistakes to avoid, and how to customize for your niche. Writing this from scratch would take you 4-6 hours. Or...
Get Your Influencer Managers Emails Written In Under 5 Minutes.
You've got the blueprints. Now get them built. Answer a few questions about your influencer managers offer and get all 7 emails written for you. Your voice. Your offer. Ready to send.
Stop guessing what to write. These are the emails that sell influencer managers offers.
One-time payment. No subscription. Credits valid 12 months.